Best Sellers

Monterey Jack Cheese with Ghost Peppers and Habaneros

Monterey Jack Cheese with Ghost Peppers and Habaneros

23 Customer Ratings
Turn up the heat! This Ghost Pepper Monterey Jack has taken the traditional notion of Pepper J...
$6.75
Add to Cart
Havarti Cheese Horseradish and Chive

Havarti Cheese Horseradish and Chive

67 Customer Ratings
Decatur Dairy produces award-winning Wisconsin Havarti Cheeses. Steve Stettler and his talent...
$4.00
Add to Cart
Monterey Jack Cheese with Pepper

Monterey Jack Cheese with Pepper

24 Customer Ratings
Take smooth, mellow Monterey Jack, add bits of fiery jalapeno peppers, and you have Wisconsin ...
$4.25
$3.75
Add to Cart
Hot and Spicy Cheese Gift Basket

Hot and Spicy Cheese Gift Basket

25 Customer Ratings
If you're looking for a Wisconsin gift basket to set your mouth on fire, search no further. Th...
$46.00
Add to Cart
Cheddar Cheese Mango Fire

Cheddar Cheese Mango Fire

22 Customer Ratings
A new flavor from Henning's creamery. This cheddar is combined with fruity mango and fiery hab...
$6.25
$5.50
Add to Cart
Monterey Jack Cheese with Habanero

Monterey Jack Cheese with Habanero

28 Customer Ratings
Made by Maple Leaf Cheese Cooperative in Monroe Wisconsin, this is a cheese whose spice you ca...
$4.25
Add to Cart
Carolina Reaper Cheddar Angel de la Muerte

Carolina Reaper Cheddar Angel de la Muerte

8 Customer Ratings
This is the spiciest cheese we carry! Made with Caralina Reaper peppers which are bred in a Ro...
$5.50
Add to Cart
Ghost Scorpion Pepper Cheese Diablo

Ghost Scorpion Pepper Cheese Diablo

0 Customer Ratings
This young yellow cheddar brings the heat! Infused with scorpion and ghost peppers (some of th...
$5.50
Add to Cart
Spicy Beer Cheese Spread

Spicy Beer Cheese Spread

0 Customer Ratings
Established in 1963 in Newton, Wisconsin, Pine River is family owned and operated by the Linde...
$4.25
Add to Cart
Smoked Wisconsin Pepper Jack Cheese

Smoked Wisconsin Pepper Jack Cheese

0 Customer Ratings
The supple and smooth Pepper Jack cheese is home to two very complimentary flavors - smoke and...
$5.75
Add to Cart
Yogurt Cheese Chipotle Lactose Free

Yogurt Cheese Chipotle Lactose Free

0 Customer Ratings
Cultured Way Chipotle Yogurt Cheese is a tangy, spicy and low-sodium Wisconsin cheese. This Wi...
$4.00
Add to Cart
Muscoda Mayhem Colby Jack

Muscoda Mayhem Colby Jack

0 Customer Ratings
Colby-Jack is a cheese produced from a mixture of Colby and Monterey Jack cheeses. This natura...
$6.25
Add to Cart
Juusto with Chipotle Peppers

Juusto with Chipotle Peppers

0 Customer Ratings
Juusto is a Finnish cheese known as bread cheese. Juusto has a baked caramelized crust that ...
$7.50
Add to Cart