Best Sellers

Havarti Cheese Horseradish and Chive

Havarti Cheese Horseradish and Chive

70 Customer Ratings
Decatur Dairy produces award-winning Wisconsin Havarti Cheeses. Steve Stettler and his talent...
$5.25
Add to Cart
Artisan Assortment Gift Box

Artisan Assortment Gift Box

91 Customer Ratings
A hand-picked assortment of blue ribbon winning cheeses. These specialty cheeses are not only ...
$92.00
Add to Cart
Hot and Spicy Cheese Gift Basket

Hot and Spicy Cheese Gift Basket

31 Customer Ratings
If you're looking for a Wisconsin gift basket to set your mouth on fire, search no further. Th...
$42.00
Add to Cart
Cheddar Cheese Mango Fire

Cheddar Cheese Mango Fire

23 Customer Ratings
Henning's Mango Fire Cheddar is a new cheese flavor from Henning's Creamery in Kiel, Wisconsin...
$7.00
Add to Cart
Carolina Reaper Cheddar Angel de la Muerte

Carolina Reaper Cheddar Angel de la Muerte

11 Customer Ratings
Angel de la Muerte is the spiciest Wisconsin cheese we carry! Carolina Reaper peppers, with ov...
$7.00
Add to Cart
Dunbarton Blue Cheese

Dunbarton Blue Cheese

85 Customer Ratings
Made by Roelli Cheese in Shullsburg, Wisconsin. This cutting edge Wisconsin Cheese combines al...
$14.75
Add to Cart
Monterey Jack Cheese with Habanero

Monterey Jack Cheese with Habanero

31 Customer Ratings
Made by Maple Leaf Cheese Cooperative in Monroe Wisconsin, this is a cheese whose spice you ca...
$4.75
Add to Cart
Ghost Scorpion Pepper Cheese Diablo

Ghost Scorpion Pepper Cheese Diablo

0 Customer Ratings
El Sancho Diablo cheese, made by Cesar's Creamery in Sheboygan Falls, Wisconsin, is a young an...
$7.00
Add to Cart
Pleasant Ridge Reserve Cheese

Pleasant Ridge Reserve Cheese

48 Customer Ratings
Wisconsin Pleasant Ridge Reserve Cheese is an artisanal cheese made from the non-pasteurized m...
$14.50
Add to Cart
Spicy Beer Cheese Spread

Spicy Beer Cheese Spread

0 Customer Ratings
Established in 1963 in Newton, Wisconsin, Pine River is family owned and operated by the Linde...
$4.95
Add to Cart
Olli Calabrese Salami Sausage

Olli Calabrese Salami Sausage

3 Customer Ratings
Calabrese is a spicy salami that gets its kick from cayenne pepper and paprika. This Calabrese...
$13.00
Add to Cart
Reaper Cheese Curds

Reaper Cheese Curds

0 Customer Ratings
This fresh Wisconsin cheddar curd is the spiciest available in our store, drawing in lovers of...
$7.25
Add to Cart
Roelli Cheddar Red Rock Cheese

Roelli Cheddar Red Rock Cheese

30 Customer Ratings
Made by Roelli Cheese in Shullsburg, Wisconsin. This cutting edge Wisconsin Cheese combines al...
$11.00
Add to Cart
Spicy Irishman Whiskey Cheddar

Spicy Irishman Whiskey Cheddar

2 Customer Ratings
A Wisconsin Cheese Mart exclusive: Spicy Irishman Whiskey Cheddar! A delicious Wisconsin whit...
$8.00
$6.80
Add to Cart
Cheddar Cheese Snow White Goat

Cheddar Cheese Snow White Goat

1 Customer Rating
In ancient times, underground caves provided the ideal environment for aging cheese. In more...
$11.00
Add to Cart
Tequila Reaper Patron Cheddar

Tequila Reaper Patron Cheddar

6 Customer Ratings
A Wisconsin Cheese Mart exclusive: Tequila Reaper Patron Cheddar! A delicious Wisconsin white...
$8.50
Add to Cart
Ghost Pepper Cheese Spread

Ghost Pepper Cheese Spread

0 Customer Ratings
Cold pack cheese spread is made by blending cuts of grade A Wisconsin state brand natural Ched...
$4.95
Add to Cart