Best Sellers

Cheddar Peppercorn Cheese

Cheddar Peppercorn Cheese

23 Customer Ratings
This Peppercorn Cheddar is made in Kiel Wisconsin by Hennings creamery. This unique Cheddar wa...
$7.00
Add to Cart
Pleasant Ridge Reserve Cheese

Pleasant Ridge Reserve Cheese

48 Customer Ratings
Wisconsin Pleasant Ridge Reserve Cheese is an artisanal cheese made from the non-pasteurized m...
$14.50
Add to Cart
Farmers Basil Cheese

Farmers Basil Cheese

6 Customer Ratings
Farmers cheese originated on farms as a way to use milk left over after skimming the cream for...
$5.50
Add to Cart
Reaper Cheese Curds

Reaper Cheese Curds

0 Customer Ratings
This fresh Wisconsin cheddar curd is the spiciest available in our store, drawing in lovers of...
$7.25
Add to Cart
Roelli Cheddar Red Rock Cheese

Roelli Cheddar Red Rock Cheese

30 Customer Ratings
Made by Roelli Cheese in Shullsburg, Wisconsin. This cutting edge Wisconsin Cheese combines al...
$11.00
Add to Cart
Gouda Cheese Marieke Bacon

Gouda Cheese Marieke Bacon

10 Customer Ratings
Hollands Family Cheeses award winning Marieke Gouda is now available with bacon. Hollands Fami...
$11.00
Add to Cart
Swiss Almond Cheese Spread

Swiss Almond Cheese Spread

3 Customer Ratings
Cold pack cheese spread is made by blending cuts of grade A Wisconsin state brand natural Ched...
$4.95
Add to Cart
Spicy Irishman Whiskey Cheddar

Spicy Irishman Whiskey Cheddar

2 Customer Ratings
A Wisconsin Cheese Mart exclusive: Spicy Irishman Whiskey Cheddar! A delicious Wisconsin whit...
$8.00
$6.80
Add to Cart
Carr Valley Bread Cheese with Garlic

Carr Valley Bread Cheese with Garlic

2 Customer Ratings
Inspired by the Finnish cheese Juustoleipa, or cheese bread. This "squeaky" cheese has a very ...
$5.50
Add to Cart
Cheddar Cheese Cherry

Cheddar Cheese Cherry

0 Customer Ratings
This double milled aged white cheddar from Maple Leaf Cheese in Monroe, Wisconsin is mixed wit...
$5.75
Add to Cart
Cheddar Cheese Snow White Goat

Cheddar Cheese Snow White Goat

1 Customer Rating
In ancient times, underground caves provided the ideal environment for aging cheese. In more...
$11.00
Add to Cart
Beer Cheese Rye Stout

Beer Cheese Rye Stout

0 Customer Ratings
This creamy cheddar cheese features Wisconsin s own 3 Sheep's Brewing Co. Cashmere Hammer, a...
$6.50
Add to Cart
Makers Mark Cheddar

Makers Mark Cheddar

0 Customer Ratings
This Wisconsin white cheddar is infused with Maker's Mark Bourbon! This creamy Cheddar has un...
$8.50
$7.75
Add to Cart
Pimento Cheese Spread

Pimento Cheese Spread

1 Customer Rating
Established in 1963 in Newton, Wisconsin, Pine River is family owned and operated by the Linde...
$4.95
Add to Cart
Horseradish Cheese Spread

Horseradish Cheese Spread

0 Customer Ratings
Established in 1963 in Newton, Wisconsin, Pine River is family owned and operated by the Linde...
$4.95
Add to Cart
Halloumi Cheese

Halloumi Cheese

1 Customer Rating
Halloumi is a semi-hard, unripened, brined cheese made from a mixture of cow, sheep, and goat'...
$7.50
Add to Cart
Tequila Reaper Patron Cheddar

Tequila Reaper Patron Cheddar

6 Customer Ratings
A Wisconsin Cheese Mart exclusive: Tequila Reaper Patron Cheddar! A delicious Wisconsin white...
$8.50
Add to Cart
Beer Cheese Milk Stout

Beer Cheese Milk Stout

2 Customer Ratings
This creamy cheddar cheese features Wisconsin s own MKE Brewery Milk Stout, a rich and milky...
$6.50
Add to Cart