Cheese By Type

Cheddar Cheese 5 Year Old Extra Sharp

Cheddar Cheese 5 Year Old Extra Sharp

117 Customer Ratings
Wisconsin is leading in Cheddar production, which makes it no surprise that this Cheddar is on...
$5.00
Add to Cart
Havarti Cheese Horseradish and Chive

Havarti Cheese Horseradish and Chive

68 Customer Ratings
Decatur Dairy produces award-winning Wisconsin Havarti Cheeses. Steve Stettler and his talent...
$5.25
Add to Cart
Dubliner Irish Cheddar

Dubliner Irish Cheddar

0 Customer Ratings
A robust aged cow's milk cheese with a bit of a hard texture similar to Cheddar. A diversity ...
$4.75
Add to Cart
Cheddar Cheese Blueberry White

Cheddar Cheese Blueberry White

24 Customer Ratings
This double milled aged white cheddar from Maple Leaf Cheese in Monroe, Wisconsin is mixed wit...
$5.25
Add to Cart
Cheddar Cheese Wisconsin Medium 4oz

Cheddar Cheese Wisconsin Medium 4oz

16 Customer Ratings
This is 4 ounces of wax covered Wisconsin mild cheddar cheese in the shape of the state of Wis...
$5.25
Add to Cart
Cheddar Cheese Cranberry White

Cheddar Cheese Cranberry White

21 Customer Ratings
This double milled aged white cheddar from Maple Leaf Cheese in Monroe, Wisconsin is mixed wit...
$5.25
Add to Cart
Bellavitano Espresso

Bellavitano Espresso

37 Customer Ratings
The Bellavitano style, unique to Wisconsin, features a rich and creamy texture with a great, c...
$5.25
Add to Cart
Bellavitano New Glarus Raspberry Tart Cheese

Bellavitano New Glarus Raspberry Tart Cheese

94 Customer Ratings
The Bellavitano style, unique to Wisconsin, features a rich and creamy texture with a great, c...
$5.25
Add to Cart
Bellavitano Merlot

Bellavitano Merlot

90 Customer Ratings
The Bellavitano style, unique to Wisconsin, features a rich and creamy texture with a great, c...
$5.25
Add to Cart
Cheddar Cheese Cherry

Cheddar Cheese Cherry

0 Customer Ratings
This double milled aged white cheddar from Maple Leaf Cheese in Monroe, Wisconsin is mixed wit...
$5.25
Add to Cart
Cheddar Cheese Sticks

Cheddar Cheese Sticks

1 Customer Rating
Enjoy the award-winning favorite that launched John W.M. Macy's business! Originally developed...
$5.25
Add to Cart
Wensleydale Cranberry Cheese

Wensleydale Cranberry Cheese

0 Customer Ratings
Creamy Wensleydale is one of England s oldest cheeses and was originally produced in the north...
$5.40
Add to Cart
Ghost Scorpion Pepper Cheese Diablo

Ghost Scorpion Pepper Cheese Diablo

0 Customer Ratings
This young yellow cheddar brings the heat! Infused with scorpion and ghost peppers (some of th...
$5.50
Add to Cart
Carolina Reaper Cheddar Angel de la Muerte

Carolina Reaper Cheddar Angel de la Muerte

8 Customer Ratings
This is the spiciest cheese we carry! Made with Carolina Reaper peppers which are bred in a Ro...
$5.50
Add to Cart
Cheddar Cheese Sharp Spread

Cheddar Cheese Sharp Spread

23 Customer Ratings
Established in 1963 in Newton, Wisconsin, Pine River is family owned and operated by the Linde...
$4.25
Add to Cart
Smoked Wisconsin Pepper Jack Cheese

Smoked Wisconsin Pepper Jack Cheese

0 Customer Ratings
The supple and smooth Pepper Jack cheese is home to two very complimentary flavors - smoke and...
$5.75
Add to Cart
Spicy Beer Cheese Spread

Spicy Beer Cheese Spread

0 Customer Ratings
Established in 1963 in Newton, Wisconsin, Pine River is family owned and operated by the Linde...
$4.25
Add to Cart
Cheddar Cheese 2 Year Aged Extra Sharp

Cheddar Cheese 2 Year Aged Extra Sharp

27 Customer Ratings
Wisconsin is leading in Cheddar production, which makes it no surprise that this Cheddar is on...
$5.75
Add to Cart
Monterey Jack Cheese with Habanero

Monterey Jack Cheese with Habanero

28 Customer Ratings
Made by Maple Leaf Cheese Cooperative in Monroe Wisconsin, this is a cheese whose spice you ca...
$4.25
Add to Cart
Cheese Cow 4oz

Cheese Cow 4oz

24 Customer Ratings
Mild Cheddar Cheese coated with cheese wax in the shape of a cow. 4oz
$4.25
Add to Cart
Gouda Cheese Smoked

Gouda Cheese Smoked

16 Customer Ratings
Gouda is a Dutch cheese named after the city of Gouda in the Netherlands. It is one of the mos...
$4.25
Add to Cart
Hickory Sticks Usingers

Hickory Sticks Usingers

0 Customer Ratings
Ready to eat, pork and beef summer sausage mini-links. Slim in appearance, huge in flavor. A t...
$5.75
Add to Cart
Cheddar Peppercorn Cheese

Cheddar Peppercorn Cheese

22 Customer Ratings
This Peppercorn Cheddar is made in Kiel Wisconsin by Hennings creamery. This unique Cheddar wa...
$5.75
Add to Cart
Yogurt Cheese Chipotle Lactose Free

Yogurt Cheese Chipotle Lactose Free

0 Customer Ratings
Cultured Way Chipotle Yogurt Cheese is a tangy, spicy and low-sodium Wisconsin cheese. This Wi...
$4.00
Add to Cart
Limburger Cheese

Limburger Cheese

8 Customer Ratings
Limburger cheese is a soft, surface ripened cheese. Limburger cheese is world renowned for bei...
$6.25
Add to Cart
Muscoda Mayhem Colby Jack

Muscoda Mayhem Colby Jack

1 Customer Rating
Colby-Jack is a cheese produced from a mixture of Colby and Monterey Jack cheeses. This natura...
$6.25
Add to Cart
Cheddar Cheese Wisconsin Small 2oz

Cheddar Cheese Wisconsin Small 2oz

15 Customer Ratings
This is 2 ounces of wax covered Wisconsin mild cheddar cheese in the shape of the state of Wis...
$3.75
Add to Cart
Cheddar Cheese Mango Fire

Cheddar Cheese Mango Fire

22 Customer Ratings
A new flavor from Henning's creamery. This cheddar is combined with fruity mango and fiery hab...
$6.25
Add to Cart
Juusto Bread Cheese with Five Year Cheddar

Juusto Bread Cheese with Five Year Cheddar

19 Customer Ratings
Juustoleipa (hoo-stah-lee-pah) means "Bread Cheese". It is a buttery flavored baked cheese tha...
$6.25
Add to Cart
Juusto Baked Bread Cheese

Juusto Baked Bread Cheese

54 Customer Ratings
Juustoleipa (yoo-stoh-lay-paa) means "Bread Cheese". It is a buttery flavored baked cheese tha...
$6.25
Add to Cart
Jarlsberg Cheese Wedge

Jarlsberg Cheese Wedge

0 Customer Ratings
Jarlsberg is a mild, semi-soft cow s milk cheese of Norwegian origin. Created by Anders Larsen...
$6.25
Add to Cart
Monterey Jack with Roasted Red Pepper

Monterey Jack with Roasted Red Pepper

8 Customer Ratings
This Monterey Jack is enhanced with Roasted Red Pepper. Wisconsin leads all other states in th...
$6.25
Add to Cart
Gjetost

Gjetost

5 Customer Ratings
A Norwegian breakfast cheese, Gjetost packs a unique sweetness. Gjetost is sweet like caramel ...
$6.50
Add to Cart
Beer Cheese Coffee Stout

Beer Cheese Coffee Stout

2 Customer Ratings
This creamy white cheese starts as curds, which are soaked in a Coffee Stout made by Lakefront...
$6.50
Add to Cart
Beer Cheese Rye Stout

Beer Cheese Rye Stout

0 Customer Ratings
This natural white cheese starts as curds, which are soaked in a nitro rye stout made by 3 She...
$6.50
Add to Cart
Cheese Cow 2oz

Cheese Cow 2oz

23 Customer Ratings
Mild Cheddar Cheese coated with cheese wax in the shape of a cow. 2oz
$3.45
Add to Cart
Monterey Jack Cheese with Morel and Leek

Monterey Jack Cheese with Morel and Leek

22 Customer Ratings
This Monterey Jack is enhanced with Morel and Leek. Wisconsin leads all other states in the pr...
$6.75
Add to Cart
Monterey Jack Cheese with Ghost Peppers and Habaneros

Monterey Jack Cheese with Ghost Peppers and Habaneros

23 Customer Ratings
Turn up the heat! This Ghost Pepper Monterey Jack has taken the traditional notion of Pepper J...
$6.75
Add to Cart
Leyden Cheese

Leyden Cheese

0 Customer Ratings
Leyden originates from the Netherlands. It is made with skimmed milk and creamy buttermilk res...
$6.75
Add to Cart
Hooks Five Year Sharp Cheddar Cheese

Hook's Five Year Sharp Cheddar Cheese

2 Customer Ratings
This Wisconsin Cheddar has been aged to perfection for five years and an international panel o...
$6.75
Add to Cart
Port Salut Cheese

Port Salut Cheese

0 Customer Ratings
Port Salut cheese is a traditional monastery cheese originally created in 1816 by Trappist mon...
$7.00
Add to Cart
Goat Cheese Monterey Jack

Goat Cheese Monterey Jack

0 Customer Ratings
Traditional Wisconsin cheese created from milk produced from goats on Southwest Wisconsin past...
$7.00
Add to Cart
Raclette Mountain Cheese

Raclette Mountain Cheese

0 Customer Ratings
Raclette cheese is a Swiss mountain cheese made from raw cow's milk. The unpasteurized milk co...
$7.25
Add to Cart
Brun-uusto Bread Cheese

Brun-uusto Bread Cheese

28 Customer Ratings
Brun-uusto is a Wisconsin-made 'Bread Cheese' from Brunkow Cheese of Darlington, Wisconsin. Ba...
$7.25
Add to Cart
Juusto with Chipotle Peppers

Juusto with Chipotle Peppers

0 Customer Ratings
Juusto is a Finnish cheese known as bread cheese. Juusto has a baked caramelized crust that ...
$7.50
Add to Cart
Cheddar Cheese English Hollow

Cheddar Cheese English Hollow

5 Customer Ratings
The region that is home to the Maple Leaf creamery is know as English Hollow because of the la...
$7.50
Add to Cart
Brun-Uusto Baked Cheese with Garlic

Brun-Uusto Baked Cheese with Garlic

0 Customer Ratings
Brun-uusto is a Wisconsin-made 'Bread Cheese' from Brunkow Cheese of Darlington, Wisconsin. Ba...
$7.50
Add to Cart
Saxon Pastures Cheese

Saxon Pastures Cheese

8 Customer Ratings
Pastures is bandaged-wrapped, Old English-style Cheddar. a meaty cheese, young, but dense, mel...
$7.50
Add to Cart
Juusto Baked Bread Cheese with Bacon

Juusto Baked Bread Cheese with Bacon

1 Customer Rating
Juusto with Nueske s Bacon is a combination of Juusto cheese and Wisconsin-made Nueske s appl...
$7.50
Add to Cart
San Simon Cheese

San Simon Cheese

0 Customer Ratings
San Simon is a smoked cow milk cheese from Galicia in the shape of a teardrop. It is caramel c...
$7.50
Add to Cart
Cheddar Cheese Mild Wheel

Cheddar Cheese Mild Wheel

15 Customer Ratings
This Wisconsin cheese is an everyday cheese with an out-of-this-world taste. This Wisconsin Ch...
$7.75
Add to Cart
Manchego Curado

Manchego Curado

0 Customer Ratings
This Spanish sheep's milk cheese is aged in natural caves for at least three months. It has a ...
$8.00
Add to Cart
Colby Cheese Shullsburg

Colby Cheese Shullsburg

21 Customer Ratings
Wisconsin original cheese! The first Colby was made in 1874 in Colby, Wisconsin. The cheese...
$8.25
Add to Cart
Cheddar Cheese Medium Aged Wheel

Cheddar Cheese Medium Aged Wheel

13 Customer Ratings
This Wisconsin cheese is an everyday cheese with an out-of-this-world taste. A Cheddar that wo...
$8.50
Add to Cart
Grand Cru Reserve

Grand Cru Reserve

0 Customer Ratings
Grand Cru Reserve is aged a minimum of nine months to create a firm texture and complex flavor...
$8.65
Add to Cart
Limburger Cheese Spread

Limburger Cheese Spread

0 Customer Ratings
A real Limburger cheese spread, that you have been looking for. Made by the last factory in th...
$8.75
Add to Cart
String Cheese Old-Fashioned

String Cheese Old-Fashioned

21 Customer Ratings
Unlike its grocery store cousin this string cheese is made the old fashioned way. First it's k...
$8.75
Add to Cart
String Cheese Smoked

String Cheese Smoked

39 Customer Ratings
Unlike its grocery store cousin this string cheese is made the old fashioned way. First it's k...
$8.75
Add to Cart
Blue Affinee Cheese

Blue Affinee Cheese

19 Customer Ratings
Blue Affinee is by far our creamiest and strongest blue. This blue cheese is made from unpast...
$8.75
Add to Cart
Cheddar Cheese Sharp Wheel

Cheddar Cheese Sharp Wheel

17 Customer Ratings
This Wisconsin cheese is an everyday cheese with an out-of-this-world taste. Aged at least 9 ...
$9.00
Add to Cart