Cheese By Type

Cheddar Cheese Cranberry White

Cheddar Cheese Cranberry White

18 Customer Ratingss
This double milled aged white cheddar from Maple Leaf Cheese in Monroe, Wisconsin is mixed wit...
$5.25
Add to Cart
Cheddar Cheese Wisconsin Medium 4oz

Cheddar Cheese Wisconsin Medium 4oz

14 Customer Ratingss
This is 4 ounces of wax covered Wisconsin mild cheddar cheese in the shape of the state of Wis...
$5.25
Add to Cart
Bellavitano New Glarus Raspberry Tart Cheese

Bellavitano New Glarus Raspberry Tart Cheese

94 Customer Ratingss
The Bellavitano style, unique to Wisconsin, features a rich and creamy texture with a great, c...
$5.25
Add to Cart
Cheddar Cheese Blueberry White

Cheddar Cheese Blueberry White

23 Customer Ratingss
This double milled aged white cheddar from Maple Leaf Cheese in Monroe, Wisconsin is mixed wit...
$5.25
Add to Cart
Bellavitano Merlot

Bellavitano Merlot

87 Customer Ratingss
The Bellavitano style, unique to Wisconsin, features a rich and creamy texture with a great, c...
$5.25
Add to Cart
Bellavitano Espresso

Bellavitano Espresso

37 Customer Ratingss
The Bellavitano style, unique to Wisconsin, features a rich and creamy texture with a great, c...
$5.25
Add to Cart
Limburger Cheese

Limburger Cheese

8 Customer Ratingss
Limburger cheese is a soft, surface ripened cheese. Limburger cheese is world renowned for bei...
$5.25
Add to Cart
Cheddar Angel De La Muerte

Cheddar Angel De La Muerte

0 Customer Ratingss
This is the spiciest cheese we carry! Made with Caralina Reaper peppers which are bred in a Ro...
$5.50
Add to Cart
Juusto Baked Bread Cheese

Juusto Baked Bread Cheese

49 Customer Ratingss
Juustoleipa (yoo-stoh-lay-paa) means "Bread Cheese". It is a buttery flavored baked cheese tha...
$5.50
Add to Cart
Cheddar Cheese Sharp Spread

Cheddar Cheese Sharp Spread

21 Customer Ratingss
Established in 1963 in Newton, Wisconsin, Pine River is family owned and operated by the Linde...
$4.25
Add to Cart
Monterey Jack Cheese with Habanero

Monterey Jack Cheese with Habanero

28 Customer Ratingss
Made by Maple Leaf Cheese Cooperative in Monroe Wisconsin, this is a cheese whose spice you ca...
$4.25
Add to Cart
Beer Cheese Coffee Stout

Beer Cheese Coffee Stout

1 Customer Ratings
This creamy white cheese starts as curds, which are soaked in a Coffee Stout made by Lakefront...
$5.75
$4.25
Add to Cart
Cheddar Cheese 2 Year Aged Extra Sharp

Cheddar Cheese 2 Year Aged Extra Sharp

25 Customer Ratingss
Wisconsin is leading in Cheddar production, which makes it no surprise that this Cheddar is on...
$5.75
Add to Cart
Cheese Cow 4oz

Cheese Cow 4oz

24 Customer Ratingss
Mild Cheddar Cheese coated with cheese wax in the shape of a cow. 4oz
$4.25
Add to Cart
Gouda Cheese Smoked

Gouda Cheese Smoked

16 Customer Ratingss
Gouda is a Dutch cheese named after the city of Gouda in the Netherlands. It is one of the mos...
$4.25
Add to Cart
Beer Cheese Milk Stout

Beer Cheese Milk Stout

3 Customer Ratingss
This natural white cheese starts as curds, which are soaked in a Milk Stout made by Milwaukee ...
$5.72
$4.25
Add to Cart
Monterey Jack Cheese with Pepper

Monterey Jack Cheese with Pepper

23 Customer Ratingss
Take smooth, mellow Monterey Jack, add bits of fiery jalapeno peppers, and you have Wisconsin ...
$4.25
Add to Cart
Cheddar Peppercorn Cheese

Cheddar Peppercorn Cheese

19 Customer Ratingss
This cave aged type cheddar is dryer due to the air curing and the addition of whole peppercor...
$5.75
Add to Cart
Cheddar Cheese 5 Year Old Extra Sharp

Cheddar Cheese 5 Year Old Extra Sharp

114 Customer Ratingss
Wisconsin is leading in Cheddar production, which makes it no surprise that this Cheddar is on...
$5.75
Add to Cart
Smokey Bacon Snack Spread

Smokey Bacon Snack Spread

0 Customer Ratingss
Established in 1963 in Newton, Wisconsin, Pine River is family owned and operated by the Linde...
$4.25
Add to Cart
Monterey Jack Cheese with Ghost Peppers and Habaneros

Monterey Jack Cheese with Ghost Peppers and Habaneros

21 Customer Ratingss
Turn up the heat! This Ghost Pepper Monterey Jack has taken the traditional notion of Pepper J...
$5.75
Add to Cart
Cheddar Cheese 5 Year Extra Sharp White

Cheddar Cheese 5 Year Extra Sharp White

8 Customer Ratingss
Wisconsin is leading in Cheddar production, which makes it no surprise that aged Cheddar is on...
$6.00
Add to Cart
Roelli Cheddar Red Rock Cheese

Roelli Cheddar Red Rock Cheese

0 Customer Ratingss
Made by Roelli Cheese in Shullsburg, Wisconsin. This cutting edge Wisconsin Cheese combines al...
$8.75
$6.00
Add to Cart
Havarti Cheese

Havarti Cheese

0 Customer Ratingss
Havarti is a deliciously mild, very creamy, natural, semi-soft cheese. This interior-ripened c...
$4.00
Add to Cart
Havarti Cheese Horseradish and Chive

Havarti Cheese Horseradish and Chive

64 Customer Ratingss
Decatur Dairy produces award-winning Wisconsin Havarti Cheeses. Steve Stettler and his talent...
$4.00
Add to Cart
Caerphilly Nut Brown Ale Cheese

Caerphilly Nut Brown Ale Cheese

7 Customer Ratingss
This pure white cheese starts with curds, which are soaked in a Nut Brown Ale, pressed, bandag...
$6.00
Add to Cart
Cheddar Cheese Wisconsin Small 2oz

Cheddar Cheese Wisconsin Small 2oz

15 Customer Ratingss
This is 2 ounces of wax covered Wisconsin mild cheddar cheese in the shape of the state of Wis...
$3.75
Add to Cart
Cheddar Cheese Mango Fire

Cheddar Cheese Mango Fire

21 Customer Ratingss
A new flavor from Henning's creamery. This cheddar is combined with fruity mango and fiery hab...
$6.25
Add to Cart
Oven Baked Juusto Bread Cheese with Five Year Cheddar

Oven Baked Juusto Bread Cheese with Five Year Cheddar

18 Customer Ratingss
Juustoleipa (hoo-stah-lee-pah) means "Bread Cheese". It is a buttery flavored baked cheese tha...
$6.25
Add to Cart
Saxon Pastures Cheese

Saxon Pastures Cheese

7 Customer Ratingss
Made in Cleveland WI, by Saxon Homestead Creamery, Pastures is a meaty cheese, young, but dens...
$6.25
Add to Cart
Monterey Jack Cheese with Morel and Leek

Monterey Jack Cheese with Morel and Leek

20 Customer Ratingss
This Monterey Jack is enhanced with Morel and Leek. Wisconsin leads all other states in the pr...
$6.75
$3.60
Add to Cart
Gjetost

Gjetost

1 Customer Ratings
A Norwegian breakfast cheese, Gjetost packs a unique sweetness. Gjetost is sweet like caramel ...
$6.50
Add to Cart
Monterey Jack with Roasted Red Pepper

Monterey Jack with Roasted Red Pepper

1 Customer Ratings
This Monterey Jack is enhanced with Roasted Red Pepper. Wisconsin leads all other states in th...
$6.25
$3.50
Add to Cart
Cheese Cow 2oz

Cheese Cow 2oz

22 Customer Ratingss
Mild Cheddar Cheese coated with cheese wax in the shape of a cow. 2oz
$3.45
Add to Cart
Colby Cheese

Colby Cheese

20 Customer Ratingss
Wisconsin original cheese! The first Colby was made in 1874 in Colby, Wisconsin. The cheese...
$7.25
Add to Cart
Brun-uusto Bread Cheese

Brun-uusto Bread Cheese

26 Customer Ratingss
Brun-uusto is a Wisconsin-made 'Bread Cheese' from Brunkow Cheese of Darlington, Wisconsin. Ba...
$7.25
Add to Cart
Edam Round

Edam Round

3 Customer Ratingss
Edam is a Dutch style cheese named after the city of Edam in the Netherlands. This sweet curd ...
$6.25
$2.60
Add to Cart
Juusto Baked Bread Cheese with Bacon

Juusto Baked Bread Cheese with Bacon

0 Customer Ratingss
Juusto with Nueske s Bacon is a combination of Juusto cheese and Wisconsin-made Nueske s appl...
$7.50
Add to Cart
Blue Affinee Cheese

Blue Affinee Cheese

19 Customer Ratingss
Blue Affinee is by far our creamiest and strongest blue. This blue cheese is made from unpast...
$7.50
Add to Cart
Cheddar Cheese Mild Wheel

Cheddar Cheese Mild Wheel

15 Customer Ratingss
This Wisconsin cheese is an everyday cheese with an out-of-this-world taste. This Wisconsin Ch...
$7.75
Add to Cart
Drunken Goat Cheese

Drunken Goat Cheese

0 Customer Ratingss
This cheese is originally called Murcia Al Vino, literally translating to ''goat with wine''. ...
$8.00
Add to Cart
Manchego Curado

Manchego Curado

0 Customer Ratingss
This Spanish sheep's milk cheese is aged in natural caves for at least three months. It has a ...
$8.00
Add to Cart
Cheddar Cheese Medium Aged Wheel

Cheddar Cheese Medium Aged Wheel

13 Customer Ratingss
This Wisconsin cheese is an everyday cheese with an out-of-this-world taste. A Cheddar that wo...
$8.50
Add to Cart
Gouda Marieke Young

Gouda Marieke Young

13 Customer Ratingss
This young gouda is mild and very creamy. Aged from 2-4 months. Rolf and Marieke Penterman emi...
$8.50
Add to Cart
Cheddar Cheese 7 Year Extra Sharp

Cheddar Cheese 7 Year Extra Sharp

43 Customer Ratingss
This 7 year Wisconsin Aged Cheddar is great for any Wisconsin Cheddar cheese fan. This Wiscons...
$8.60
Add to Cart
String Cheese Old-Fashioned

String Cheese Old-Fashioned

20 Customer Ratingss
Unlike its grocery store cousin this string cheese is made the old fashioned way. First it's k...
$8.75
Add to Cart
String Cheese Smoked

String Cheese Smoked

35 Customer Ratingss
Unlike its grocery store cousin this string cheese is made the old fashioned way. First it's k...
$8.75
Add to Cart
Cheddar Cheese Sharp Wheel

Cheddar Cheese Sharp Wheel

15 Customer Ratingss
This Wisconsin cheese is an everyday cheese with an out-of-this-world taste. Aged at least 9 ...
$9.00
Add to Cart
Brick German Cheese

Brick German Cheese

50 Customer Ratingss
First made by John Jossi around 1877, Brick is a Wisconsin original. Cured with a special smea...
$9.20
Add to Cart
Cheddar Cheese 8 Year Aged

Cheddar Cheese 8 Year Aged

1 Customer Ratings
Wisconsin is leading in Cheddar production, which makes it no surprise that this Cheddar is on...
$9.25
Add to Cart
Colby Traditonal Longhorn Cheese

Colby Traditonal Longhorn Cheese

8 Customer Ratingss
A Wisconsin original cheese! The first Colby was made in 1874 in Colby, Wisconsin. The cheese ...
$9.50
Add to Cart
Swiss Cheese Baby Smoked

Swiss Cheese Baby Smoked

15 Customer Ratingss
Wisconsin Baby Swiss is made by substituting water for the milk's whey to slow bacterial actio...
$9.50
Add to Cart
Cheddar Apple Smoked

Cheddar Apple Smoked

20 Customer Ratingss
This Wisconsin white Cheddar is apple smoked and then hand rubbed with paprika. The paprika gi...
$9.75
Add to Cart
Gouda Cheese Marieke Premium

Gouda Cheese Marieke Premium

17 Customer Ratingss
This Marieke Gouda is aged 12-18 months. Creamy & nutty this aged Marieke Gouda has developed ...
$10.00
Add to Cart
Gouda Cheese Marieke Bacon

Gouda Cheese Marieke Bacon

1 Customer Ratings
Hollands Family Cheeses award winning Marieke Gouda is now available with bacon. Hollands Fami...
$11.00
Add to Cart
Gruyere Grand Cru Surchoix Cheese

Gruyere Grand Cru Surchoix Cheese

35 Customer Ratingss
World Champion 2016 For the first time since 1988, a cheesemaker from the United States ...
$11.00
Add to Cart
Beerkaese Cheese

Beerkaese Cheese

38 Customer Ratingss
Though literally translated as "beer cheese," there is no beer in Beerkaese. The name comes fr...
$11.25
Add to Cart
Dunbarton Blue Cheese

Dunbarton Blue Cheese

82 Customer Ratingss
Made by Roelli Cheese in Shullsburg, Wisconsin. This cutting edge Wisconsin Cheese combines al...
$13.00
Add to Cart
Pleasant Ridge Reserve Cheese

Pleasant Ridge Reserve Cheese

46 Customer Ratingss
Wisconsin Pleasant Ridge Reserve Cheese is an artisanal cheese made from the non-pasteurized m...
$13.00
Add to Cart
Gouda Cheese Marieke 4 year

Gouda Cheese Marieke 4 year

16 Customer Ratingss
This Marieke Gouda has been aged 4 years and has developed some milk crystalization deposits. ...
$15.00
Add to Cart