Collection: Carr Valley Cheddar Cheese
Carr Valley’s Cheddar Cheeses showcase the best of Wisconsin’s cheesemaking tradition, blending time-honored techniques with bold, distinctive flavor. Known for their rich taste and satisfying texture, these cheddars range from smooth and mild to sharp and tangy, with carefully aged varieties offering deep complexity and character.
Perfect for snacking, cooking, or entertaining, Carr Valley’s cheddars melt beautifully into recipes, shine on cheese boards, and pair effortlessly with wines, beers, and cured meats.
-
Apple Smoked Garlic Cheddar
Vendor:Carr Valley CheeseRegular price $7.00Regular priceUnit price per -
Baby Cheddar Colored
Vendor:Carr Valley CheeseRegular price $5.00Regular priceUnit price per -
Beer Cheddar
Vendor:Carr Valley CheeseRegular price $9.00Regular priceUnit price per -
Blueberry Cheddar
Vendor:Carr Valley CheeseRegular price $9.50Regular priceUnit price per -
Cheddar 1 Year
Vendor:Carr Valley CheeseRegular price $7.00Regular priceUnit price per -
Cheddar 10 Year
Vendor:Carr Valley CheeseRegular price $19.00Regular priceUnit price per -
Cheddar 2 Year
Vendor:Carr Valley CheeseRegular price $7.75Regular priceUnit price per -
Cheddar 3 Year
Vendor:Carr Valley CheeseRegular price $8.50Regular priceUnit price per -
Cheddar 4 Year
Vendor:Carr Valley CheeseRegular price $9.50Regular priceUnit price per -
Cheddar 5 Year
Vendor:Carr Valley CheeseRegular price $10.50Regular priceUnit price per -
Cheddar 6 Year
Vendor:Carr Valley CheeseRegular price $11.75Regular priceUnit price per -
Cheddar 8 Year
Vendor:Carr Valley CheeseRegular price $16.00Regular priceUnit price per -
Cheddar 3# Gems
Vendor:Carr Valley CheeseRegular price From $36.00Regular priceUnit price per -
Cheddar Apple Smoked
Vendor:Carr Valley CheeseRegular price $11.50Regular priceUnit price per -
Cheddar Cave Aged
Vendor:Carr Valley CheeseRegular price $9.00Regular priceUnit price per -
Sold outCheddar Irish Valley
Vendor:Carr Valley CheeseRegular price $6.50Regular priceUnit price per -
Chipotle Cheddar
Vendor:Carr Valley CheeseRegular price $6.50Regular priceUnit price per -
Cranberry Cheddar
Vendor:Carr Valley CheeseRegular price $9.50Regular priceUnit price per -
Cranberry Chipotle Cheddar
Vendor:Carr Valley CheeseRegular price $7.00Regular priceUnit price per -
Garlic Cheddar
Vendor:Carr Valley CheeseRegular price $7.50Regular priceUnit price per
