Collection: Spicy Cheeses

Curious how our spicy cheeses rank in level of heat? 
Check out our Scoville Scale to see some of our most popular pepper cheeses ranked from mildest to spiciest!

16 products
  • Monterey Jack Cheese with Jalapeno Pepper
    8 ounce piece of monterey jack cheese with jalapeno peppers
    Take smooth, mellow Monterey Jack, add bits of fiery jala...
    Vendor
    Springside Cheese
    Regular price
    $5.25
    Sale price
    $5.25
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Hot and Spicy Cheese Gift Basket
    If you're looking for a Wisconsin gift basket to set your...
    Vendor
    Wisconsin Cheese Mart
    Regular price
    $42.00
    Sale price
    $42.00
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Cheddar Mango Fire
    8 ounce piece of spicy yellow cheddar cheese with mango
    Mango Fire Cheddar is a new cheese flavor from Henning's ...
    Vendor
    Henning's Cheese
    Regular price
    $8.50
    Sale price
    $8.50
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Carolina Reaper Cheddar Angel de la Muerte
    8 ounce piece of angel de la muerte spicy cheddar cheese
    Angel de la Muerte is the spiciest cheese we carry! Carol...
    Vendor
    Wisconsin Cheese Mart
    Regular price
    $8.50
    Sale price
    $8.50
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Spicy Beer Cheese Spread
    8 ounce tub of spicy beer cheese spread
    Established in 1963 in Newton, Wisconsin, Pine River is f...
    Vendor
    Pine River Pre-Pack, Inc
    Regular price
    $5.75
    Sale price
    $5.75
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Tequila Reaper Patron Cheddar
    8 ounce piece of spicy white cheddar cheese with tequila
    A Wisconsin Cheese Mart exclusive: Tequila Reaper Patron ...
    Vendor
    Wisconsin Cheese Mart
    Regular price
    $10.00
    Sale price
    $10.00
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Ghost Scorpion Pepper Cheese Diablo
    8 ounce piece of spicy white cheddar cheese
    El Sancho Diablo cheese, made by Cesar's Creamery in She...
    Vendor
    Wisconsin Cheese Mart
    Regular price
    $8.50
    Sale price
    $8.50
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Monterey Jack Cheese with Habanero
    8 ounce piece of monterey jack cheese with habanero peppers
    Made by Maple Leaf Cheese Cooperative in Monroe Wisconsin...
    Vendor
    Maple Leaf Cheese
    Regular price
    $5.75
    Sale price
    $5.75
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Spicy Irishman Whiskey Cheddar
    8 ounce piece of white cheddar with peppers and whiskey
    A Wisconsin Cheese Mart exclusive: Spicy Irishman Whiskey...
    Vendor
    Wisconsin Cheese Mart
    Regular price
    $10.00
    Sale price
    $10.00
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Ghost Pepper Cheese Spread
    Cold pack cheese spread is made by blending cuts of grade...
    Vendor
    Pine River Pre-Pack, Inc
    Regular price
    $5.75
    Sale price
    $5.75
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Mango Habanero Cheese Spread - Limited Availability!
    8 ounce tub of mango habanero cheese spread
    Cold pack cheese spread is made by blending cuts of grade...
    Vendor
    Pine River Pre-Pack, Inc
    Regular price
    $5.75
    Sale price
    $5.75
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Juusto Jalapeno
    6 ounce piece of juusto bread cheese with jalapeno peppers
    Juusto with Jalapeno Peppers is a buttery-flavored, flat ...
    Vendor
    Pasture Pride
    Regular price
    $7.50
    Sale price
    $7.50
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Colby Jack Ghost Pepper
    7 ounce piece of ghost pepper colby jack cheese
    Produced by Kindred Creamery, an offshoot of the Meister ...
    Vendor
    Kindred Creamery
    Regular price
    $6.50
    Sale price
    $6.50
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Dragon's Breath Cheddar
    8 ounces of spicy white cheddar cheese
    Turn up the heat with Dragon's Breath Cheddar Cheese! Dr...
    Vendor
    Henning's Cheese
    Regular price
    $8.25
    Sale price
    $8.25
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Chevre Chipotle Honey
    4 ounces of chipotle honey goat cheese
    Chevre is the French word for Goat’s cheese.  Most common...
    Vendor
    LaClare Family Creamery
    Regular price
    $5.50
    Sale price
    $5.50
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • String Cheese Sticks Jalapeno
    Wisconsin Smoked String Cheese Sticks are a low moisture,...
    Vendor
    Weyauwega Star Dairy
    Regular price
    $9.75
    Sale price
    $9.75
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out