Due to the severe weather across the country, many packages are experiencing delays. For more information, please click here.

Collection: Cheddar

The older the cheddar, the sharper the flavor. Many people will agree that cheddar gets better with age. Try some of our sharp cheddar cheeses.
58 products
  • 5 Year Aged Cheddar
    5 Year Aged Cheddar
    Wisconsin is leading in Cheddar production, which makes i...
    Vendor
    Wisconsin Cheese Mart
    Regular price
    $9.00
    Regular price
    Sale price
    $9.00
    Unit price
    per 
    Availability
    Sold out
  • Cheddar 7 Year Extra Sharp
    Cheddar 7 Year Extra Sharp
    Wisconsin is leading in Cheddar production, which makes i...
    Vendor
    Wisconsin Cheese Mart
    Regular price
    $11.75
    Regular price
    Sale price
    $11.75
    Unit price
    per 
    Availability
    Sold out
  • 5 Year Aged Cheddar Half Loaf
    5 Year Aged Cheddar Half Loaf
    Wisconsin is leading in Cheddar production, which makes i...
    Vendor
    Wisconsin Cheese Mart
    Regular price
    $37.00
    Regular price
    Sale price
    $37.00
    Unit price
    per 
    Availability
    Sold out
  • Cheddar Cheese Cranberry White
    Cheddar Cheese Cranberry White
    This double milled aged white cheddar from Maple Leaf Che...
    Vendor
    Maple Leaf Cheese
    Regular price
    $7.00
    Regular price
    Sale price
    $7.00
    Unit price
    per 
    Availability
    Sold out
  • Cheddar Cheese Sharp Spread
    Cheddar Cheese Sharp Spread
    Established in 1963 in Newton, Wisconsin, Pine River is f...
    Vendor
    Pine River Pre-Pack, Inc
    Regular price
    $5.75
    Regular price
    Sale price
    $5.75
    Unit price
    per 
    Availability
    Sold out
  • Cheddar Cheese Sharp Wheel
    Cheddar Cheese Sharp Wheel
    This Wisconsin cheese is an everyday cheese with an out-o...
    Vendor
    Wisconsin Cheese Mart
    Regular price
    $11.50
    Regular price
    Sale price
    $11.50
    Unit price
    per 
    Availability
    Sold out
  • Cheddar Ascent Gift Crate
    Cheddar Ascent Gift Crate
    A deliciously slow ascent into aged Wisconsin Cheddar. ...
    Vendor
    Wisconsin Cheese Mart
    Regular price
    $40.00
    Regular price
    Sale price
    $40.00
    Unit price
    per 
    Availability
    Sold out
  • Cheddar Cheese 2 Year Aged Extra Sharp
    Cheddar Cheese 2 Year Aged Extra Sharp
    Wisconsin is leading in Cheddar production, which makes i...
    Vendor
    Wisconsin Cheese Mart
    Regular price
    $7.00
    Regular price
    Sale price
    $7.00
    Unit price
    per 
    Availability
    Sold out
  • Cheddar Mango Fire
    Cheddar Mango Fire
    Henning's Mango Fire Cheddar is a cheddar cheese flavored...
    Vendor
    Henning's Cheese
    Regular price
    $8.50
    Regular price
    Sale price
    $8.50
    Unit price
    per 
    Availability
    Sold out
  • Cheddar Cheese Blueberry White
    Cheddar Cheese Blueberry White
    This double milled aged white cheddar from Maple Leaf Che...
    Vendor
    Maple Leaf Cheese
    Regular price
    $7.00
    Regular price
    Sale price
    $7.00
    Unit price
    per 
    Availability
    Sold out
  • Cheddar Apple Smoked
    Cheddar Apple Smoked
    With various cheesemaking sites located across the state ...
    Vendor
    Carr Valley Cheese
    Regular price
    $11.50
    Regular price
    Sale price
    $11.50
    Unit price
    per 
    Availability
    Sold out
  • Cheddar 23 Year Old Vintage 1997 Half Pound
    Cheddar 23 Year Old Vintage 1997 Half Pound
    Do you seek the exceptional? This 23 Year Old Cheddar isn...
    Vendor
    Wisconsin Cheese Mart
    Regular price
    $114.00
    Regular price
    Sale price
    $114.00
    Unit price
    per 
    Availability
    Sold out
  • Port Wine Cheese Spread
    Port Wine Cheese Spread
    Cold pack cheese spread is made by blending cuts of grade...
    Vendor
    Pine River Pre-Pack, Inc
    Regular price
    $5.75
    Regular price
    Sale price
    $5.75
    Unit price
    per 
    Availability
    Sold out
  • Cheddar 5 Year Extra Sharp White
    Cheddar 5 Year Extra Sharp White
    Wisconsin is leading in Cheddar production, which makes i...
    Vendor
    Wisconsin Cheese Mart
    Regular price
    $9.00
    Regular price
    Sale price
    $9.00
    Unit price
    per 
    Availability
    Sold out
  • Cheddar Cheese Medium Wheel
    Cheddar Cheese Medium Wheel
    This Wisconsin cheese is an everyday cheese with an out-o...
    Vendor
    Wisconsin Cheese Mart
    Regular price
    $11.50
    Regular price
    Sale price
    $11.50
    Unit price
    per 
    Availability
    Sold out
  • Cheddar Cheese 1 Year Extra Sharp White Half Loaf
    Cheddar Cheese 1 Year Extra Sharp White Half Loaf
    Wisconsin is leading in Cheddar production, which makes i...
    Vendor
    Wisconsin Cheese Mart
    Regular price
    $26.00
    Regular price
    Sale price
    $26.00
    Unit price
    per 
    Availability
    Sold out
  • Cheddar Smoked Cheese
    Cheddar Smoked Cheese
    This naturally smoked Wisconsin Cheddar cheese is a perfe...
    Vendor
    Maple Leaf Cheese
    Regular price
    $10.50
    Regular price
    Sale price
    $10.50
    Unit price
    per 
    Availability
    Sold out
  • Dunbarton Blue
    Dunbarton Blue
    Made by Roelli Cheese in Shullsburg, Wisconsin. This cutt...
    Vendor
    Roelli Cheese Haus
    Regular price
    $17.00
    Regular price
    Sale price
    $17.00
    Unit price
    per 
    Availability
    Sold out
  • Cheddar Wheel Five Pound
    Cheddar Wheel Five Pound
    Wisconsin is the leading producer of Cheddar cheese in th...
    Vendor
    Springside Cheese
    Regular price
    $44.00
    Regular price
    Sale price
    $44.00
    Unit price
    per 
    Availability
    Sold out
  • Carolina Reaper Cheddar Angel de la Muerte
    Carolina Reaper Cheddar Angel de la Muerte
    This is the spiciest cheese we carry! Made with Carolina ...
    Vendor
    Wisconsin Cheese Mart
    Regular price
    $8.50
    Regular price
    Sale price
    $8.50
    Unit price
    per 
    Availability
    Sold out
  • Beer Cheese Coffee Stout
    Beer Cheese Coffee Stout
    This creamy white cheese starts as curds, which are soake...
    Vendor
    Wisconsin Cheese Mart
    Regular price
    $8.00
    Regular price
    Sale price
    $8.00
    Unit price
    per 
    Availability
    Sold out
  • Cheddar Black Wax Wheel Three Pound
    Cheddar Black Wax Wheel Three Pound
    Three full pounds of Wisconsin-made medium cheddar cheese...
    Vendor
    Renard's Cheese
    Regular price
    $37.00
    Regular price
    Sale price
    $37.00
    Unit price
    per 
    Availability
    Sold out
  • Cheddar Cheese Mild Wheel
    Cheddar Cheese Mild Wheel
    This Wisconsin cheese is an everyday cheese with an out-o...
    Vendor
    Wisconsin Cheese Mart
    Regular price
    $11.50
    Regular price
    Sale price
    $11.50
    Unit price
    per 
    Availability
    Sold out
  • Juusto Bread Cheese with Five Year Cheddar
    Juusto Bread Cheese with Five Year Cheddar
    Juustoleipa (hoo-stah-lee-pah) means 'Bread Cheese'. It i...
    Vendor
    Pasture Pride
    Regular price
    $8.00
    Regular price
    Sale price
    $8.00
    Unit price
    per 
    Availability
    Sold out