Collection: Cheddar

The older the cheddar, the sharper the flavor. Many people will agree that cheddar gets better with age. Try some of our sharp cheddar cheeses.
61 products
  • Dunbarton Blue
    Made by Roelli Cheese in Shullsburg, Wisconsin. This cutt...
    Vendor
    Roelli Cheese Haus
    Regular price
    $17.00
    Sale price
    $17.00
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Carolina Reaper Cheddar Angel de la Muerte
    This is the spiciest cheese we carry! Made with Carolina ...
    Vendor
    Wisconsin Cheese Mart
    Regular price
    $8.50
    Sale price
    $8.50
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Cheddar Smoked Cheese
    This naturally smoked Wisconsin Cheddar cheese is a perfe...
    Vendor
    Maple Leaf Cheese
    Regular price
    $10.50
    Sale price
    $10.50
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Cheddar Wheel Five Pound
    Wisconsin is the leading producer of Cheddar cheese in th...
    Vendor
    Springside Cheese
    Regular price
    $44.00
    Sale price
    $44.00
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Beer Cheese Coffee Stout
    This creamy white cheese starts as curds, which are soake...
    Vendor
    Wisconsin Cheese Mart
    Regular price
    $8.00
    Sale price
    $8.00
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Cheddar Black Wax Wheel Three Pound
    Three full pounds of Wisconsin-made medium cheddar cheese...
    Vendor
    Renard's Cheese
    Regular price
    $37.00
    Sale price
    $37.00
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Cheddar Cheese Mild Wheel
    This Wisconsin cheese is an everyday cheese with an out-o...
    Vendor
    Wisconsin Cheese Mart
    Regular price
    $11.50
    Sale price
    $11.50
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Juusto Bread Cheese with Five Year Cheddar
    Juustoleipa (hoo-stah-lee-pah) means 'Bread Cheese'. It i...
    Vendor
    Pasture Pride
    Regular price
    $8.00
    Sale price
    $8.00
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Tequila Reaper Patron Cheddar
    A Wisconsin Cheese Mart exclusive: Tequila Reaper Patron ...
    Vendor
    Wisconsin Cheese Mart
    Regular price
    $10.00
    Sale price
    $10.00
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Cheddar Cheese 10 Year Old Extra Sharp
    Wisconsin is leading in Cheddar production, which makes i...
    Vendor
    Wisconsin Cheese Mart
    Regular price
    $22.00
    Sale price
    $22.00
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Cheddar Peppercorn Cheese
    This Peppercorn Cheddar is made in Kiel Wisconsin by Henn...
    Vendor
    Henning's Cheese
    Regular price
    $8.50
    Sale price
    $8.50
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Makers Mark White Cheddar
    This Wisconsin white cheddar is infused with Maker's Mark...
    Vendor
    Wisconsin Cheese Mart
    Regular price
    $10.00
    Sale price
    $10.00
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Cheddar Cheese Sharp Spread - 1 Pound
    Established in 1963 in Newton, Wisconsin, Pine River is f...
    Vendor
    Pine River Pre-Pack, Inc
    Regular price
    $9.00
    Sale price
    $9.00
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Cheddar Cheese Cherry
    This double milled aged white cheddar from Maple Leaf Che...
    Vendor
    Maple Leaf Cheese
    Regular price
    $7.00
    Sale price
    $7.00
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Ghost Scorpion Pepper Cheese Diablo
    This young yellow cheddar brings the heat! Infused with s...
    Vendor
    Wisconsin Cheese Mart
    Regular price
    $8.50
    Sale price
    $8.50
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Crock Sharp Cheddar - Blue
    Enjoy this Pine River Sharp Cheddar spread, made with rea...
    Vendor
    Pine River Pre-Pack
    Regular price
    $20.75
    Sale price
    $20.75
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out